She Killed Her Best Friend at 16 – Now She’s Trapped Forever 

She Killed Her Best Friend at 16 – Now She’s Trapped Forever

Imagine being 16 years old, sitting in the back of a car with your two best friends on a warm July night. You’re laughing. You’re singing. You feel completely safe. Why wouldn’t you? These are the girls you tell everything to. The girls you’ve known for years. But for Skyler niece, that car ride was the last thing she ever experienced because her two best friends had already decided tonight was the night they were going to kill her.

And the most disturbing part, they had been planning it for months. Today, we’re going deep, not just into the murder of Skyla Nice, but into what happened to the girl who masterminded it all. Sheila Eddie, the girl who smiled, the girl who never broke, and the girl who is now spending every single day of the rest of her life behind bars.

And trust me, what that life actually looks like is far worse than anything you can imagine. Before we talk about the killer, we need to talk about the victim because Skyla Nice deserves to be remembered as more than just a headline. Skyla was 16 years old, living in Star City, West Virginia. By every account, she was a normal teenager, funny, loyal, obsessed with YouTube, and completely devoted to her two best friends, Sheila Eddie and Rachel Schae.

The three of them were inseparable. People who knew them called them the three musketeers. Skylar’s parents, Dave and Mary niece, described their daughter as warm, bright, and full of life. She had dreams. She had a future. She had no idea that the two people she trusted most in the world were quietly plotting her death.

On July 5th, 2012, Skylar snuck out of her bedroom window late at night. She got into a car with Sheila and Rachel. and she was never seen alive again. Now, before we get into the night of the murder, I want you to understand something. Sheila Eddie was not some stranger. She was not some random person who crossed Skylar’s path.

She was her best friend of 8 years. 8 years. They had met as little girls at a local children’s activity program called The Shack. They were 8 years old. They grew up together. That is not a casual friendship. That is someone who knew Skylar’s family, who knew her secrets, who knew her laugh, who knew everything about her.

Sheila’s home life was not easy. Her parents divorced in 2000 after her father was involved in a car accident that left him with a traumatic brain injury. She was raised largely by her mother, and according to people who knew the family, Skylar’s home became almost a second home for Sheila. Skylar’s mother, Mary, described Sheila as someone who didn’t even knock on the door when she came over. She just walked right in.

She was accepted as part of the family. Dave and Mary niece treated Sheila like one of their own. They loved her. They trusted her completely. And Skylar, Skylar’s mother said her daughter genuinely believed she could save Sheila. She would get on the phone and give Sheila a hard time whenever she made bad decisions, telling her not to be stupid.

asking her what she was thinking. Skyla was fiercely loyal. She saw Sheila as someone worth protecting. That loyalty would cost her everything. In 2010, Sheila’s mother remarried and the family moved from Blackville to Morgantown, where Sheila began attending University High School, the same school as Skylar. And it was there that the third piece of this story entered the picture.

Rachel Schae, a talented actress and singer who quickly became close with both girls. But here is what you need to understand about Sheila specifically. From the very beginning, she was described as the dominant personality in the group. When investigators later interviewed both girls, they noted that the two were like night and day.

Rachel was nervous, distracted, wouldn’t make eye contact. Sheila. She looked investigators directly in the eyes. She was calm. She was collected. She showed no signs of nervousness whatsoever. That tells you everything about who Sheila Eddie is. Even while being questioned about her missing best friend, a girl she had already murdered and buried.

PART1

She sat there cool as anything and lied directly to their faces. This was not someone acting out of panic or impulse. in the trunk of the car the night they picked up Skylar. Investigators later found that Sheila and Rachel had hidden cleaning rags, bleach, wet wipes, a shovel, and a clean change of clothes for each of them.

They had planned every detail. They knew exactly what they were going to do, and they did it anyway. And then, and this is the part that still makes people’s skin crawl, Sheila posted regularly on Twitter about her thoughts and day-to-day activities. while authorities searched for her missing friend, tweeting about missing Skyla, performing grief for the internet, all while knowing exactly where Skylar’s body was.

That is not a teenager who made a terrible mistake in a moment of rage. That is someone who planned a murder, carried it out, and then went home and posted about it on Twitter. And that is exactly who is now sitting inside Lake Correctional Center for the rest of her life. What happened that night took years to fully piece together, but here is what we now know.

Sheila and Rachel drove Skylar to a remote area near the Pennsylvania border. They pulled over and then without warning, both girls pulled out knives and attacked their best friend. Skyla fought back. The injuries on her hands showed she tried desperately to defend herself, but she was outnumbered. Within minutes, she was gone.

They buried her body right there on the side of the road. Then they got back in the car. And here is where it gets truly chilling. They went to get food. They carried on like nothing had happened. When Skyla was reported missing the next day, both Sheila and Rachel played the role of grieving best friends perfectly. They cried with her parents.

They made social media posts begging for Skylar to come home. Sheila even tweeted, “And I want you to really let this sink in.” Sheila tweeted, “We miss you so much, Sky.” Just days after she had buried her. The audacity, the coldness, it tells you everything you need to know about who Sheila Eddie really is. For months, investigators had very little to go on. Skylar had simply vanished.

There were no witnesses, no body, no physical evidence tying anyone to her disappearance. But detectives noticed something. The story Sheila and Rachel were telling didn’t quite add up. Surveillance footage from the night Skyla disappeared showed a car matching Sheila’s pulling up to Skylar’s apartment complex and then leaving.

But Sheila denied being there that night. Then came the crack in the case. Rachel Schae started falling apart. The guilt was eating her alive. In early 2013, she checked herself into a psychiatric facility. And when she came out, she did something Sheila never expected. She confessed everything. She told investigators exactly what happened, exactly where they buried Skylar, and exactly whose idea it was.

Sheila Eddies. In January 2013, Skylar’s remains were found in Pennsylvania, right where Rachel said they would be. And just like that, the case blew wide open. Sheila was arrested in May 2013. And unlike Rachel, who had shown at least some remorse, Sheila showed nothing. No tears, no breakdown.

Just that same cold, blank expression that would follow her all the way through to sentencing. In 2014, Sheila Eddie pleaded guilty to first-degree murder. There was no trial. The evidence was overwhelming. But her guilty plea didn’t come with any real explanation. No apology to Skylar’s parents, no breakdown, nothing. She was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Let that sink in. She was 17 years old at sentencing. She will spend every single remaining day of her life inside a prison cell. She will never graduate college, never get married, never travel, never experience anything outside of those walls again. She went in as a teenager and she will die as an old woman behind bars.

Rachel Schae because of her cooperation received 30 years. She has a chance, however slim, of one day walking free. Sheila has no such chance. And here’s what I want you to think about as we move into the next part of this video. Sheila has never publicly shown remorse, not once.

So the question becomes, what is life actually like for someone like her? Someone who feels nothing, locked away forever. Because I promise you, it is not what you think. Sheila Eddie is currently incarcerated at the Lake Correctional Center in West Virginia, a women’s maximum security facility. And before anyone says at least she has a roof over her head, let me walk you through what her daily existence actually looks like because it is brutal in ways that don’t make the news.

Sheila went into prison at 17. She’s grown up entirely within those walls. Every milestone that you and I take for granted, turning 21, finishing school, falling in love, figuring out who you are as a person, she has experienced none of that. Prison doesn’t allow you to grow in the way the real world does. Instead, you are frozen, trapped in a version of yourself that never gets to evolve.

Psychologists who study long-term incarceration describe something called institutionalization, where a person becomes so conditioned to the rigid structure of prison that they lose the ability to function outside of it. For Sheila, this is now permanent. She will never have to function outside of it. And that in its own way is a unique kind of psychological torture.

Prison has its own brutal social order. And child killers, especially those who killed someone they were close to, sit at the very bottom of that hierarchy. Inmates do not look kindly on people who murdered a friend, especially a teenage girl who trusted them completely. Sheila would have entered that facility as one of the most hated people in the building. Guards can only do so much.

The day-to-day psychological pressure from other inmates, the isolation, the targeting, the constant awareness that almost everyone around you despises you, is something that never goes away. This is the part people underestimate the most. It’s not the violence or the danger that breaks most long-term inmates.

It’s the absolute crushing monotony. Every single day looks exactly the same. Wake up. Count. Eat. Count. Work. Or sit in a cell. Count. Eat. Count. Sleep. Repeat. Forever. There is no excitement, no spontaneity, no surprises, just an endless grinding repetition that has been shown in study after study to cause severe psychological deterioration over time.

Anxiety, depression, cognitive decline, paranoia. These aren’t rare in long-term inmates. They’re almost universal. Sheila grew up in the age of social media. She used Twitter to fake grief over Skylar’s disappearance. She was a teenager online just like everyone else her age. Now she has no access to social media, no internet, no smartphones.

The world has moved on without her. New platforms, new culture, new everything. and she is completely cut off from all of it forever. And then there’s this the psychological weight of knowing there is no end, no release date to countdown to, no light at the end of the tunnel, just an infinite stretch of identical days until she dies.

Researchers have found that inmates serving life without parole experience a specific and particularly devastating form of psychological suffering. One that is distinct from even those on death row. Because at least death row has an end point. Life without parole is an endless sentence with no resolution. Many describe it as a kind of living death.

Sheila Eddie chose to take Skyla’s future and in return every single day of her own future has been taken from her. Skylanise was 16 years old. She had her whole life ahead of her. She didn’t die in some random act of violence. She was betrayed by the two people she trusted most in the world. And for a long time, it looked like they might actually get away with it. But they didn’t.

Sheila Eddie will spend every remaining day of her life inside Lake Correctional Center. And whatever she is experiencing in there, the isolation, the monotony, the psychological weight of forever, she brought entirely on herself. Skylar’s parents, Dave and Mary, have spent years keeping their daughter’s memory alive.

And I think the least we can do is remember her name, not just as a victim, but as a person. a funny, loyal, YouTube obsessed teenager who deserved so much more than what she got. If this video meant something to you, please share it, subscribe if you’re new, and drop in the comments, do you think life without parole is a harder punishment than the death penalty? I genuinely want to know what you think.

Until next time.