Her Killer was the Last Person Anyone Suspected
Her Killer was the Last Person Anyone Suspected
I used to think if you met a murderer, you’d know they were a murderer. But criminals that get away with a crime for 40 plus years, they’re able to hide the fact [music] that they are this monster. Sherry Joe Elliot, she’s getting ready for school. She was just a kid [music] minding her own business. She was walking to the school bus and never made it.
Sherry would never ever ever get in [music] a car with anybody she didn’t know. He had her for like 3 to 4 days and raped her. She was faced down in a watery ditch, shot in the back of the head. This is a very violent execution. It was one of those cases that haunted a lot of people. You see a guy walking down the street.
Is that him? Is he the one that [music] took Sherry? It went on for years and we didn’t hear anything. I thought they would never find him. Everybody liked the guy. He had no criminal history, but you never know the monsters who live next to you. Jerry Elliot wasn’t too outgoing. [music] When she was little, she didn’t venture out too much. Um, Joyce Schultz, I’m her mother.
When she was little, she just loved to color when she was like [music] 2 years old. We got her a great big thick coloring book and she colored all of that, sitting color for hours. She was very disciplined. She was riding my mother-in-law’s three-wheel bike when she was in Florida [music] when she was seven. She fell off of that and scraped her nose all up. And then my brother called me and wanted her [music] to be a flower girl for his wedding.
And so hopefully her nose would all healed up. And so she was had a purple dress and was his flower girl when he got married. Sherry Joel, she was a sweetheart. We’re not supposed to have a favorite niece or nephew. She’s basically the favorite of most people in the family, [music] but she was a loving child, very respectful.
She loved to visit with her cousins when she went to her dad’s. She and her and her dad, we divorced in [music] 72, and so she would go back and forth, visit her dad, and then come home. And it was good. She was just a normal teenager. She wouldn’t go out of the house without having everything [music] matching and every hair in place. She was very [music] shy.
When she lived with her dad for 2 years, a couple stopped and wanted directions and her friend went up to the car, but Sherry wouldn’t go up to the car. That morning, I said, “Sherry, it’s cold. Make sure and dress warm.” Cuz she had to walk like two blocks to the bus stop. One morning she was wanting to leave early and I said, “No, Sherry, it’s not safe.
” I said, “I don’t want a police come knocking on my door and tell her that you’re murdered or raped.” So that morning, she said, “Okay, love you.” And then I went to work and my husband Bob went to work. After school, she always come home and I would make yogurt and mix cool whip in it and [music] then would freeze it. So she’d come home and she would do her nails and and watch Young and the Restless and eat her yogurt. That was a daily routine.
About noon, my husband come to where I was working and he said that Sherry didn’t come home. And when I got home, she was still not home. So, it got to be late and late. I called her dad. I said, “Have you heard from Sherry?” And he said, “No.” I said, “Well, I don’t know where she’s at.” So, we called the police and they said, “Oh, well, she’s a teenager. She’s run away.
” I said, “No, she didn’t.” I said, “Because there’s nothing missing. She would never go with just the clothes on her back. She would never do that. And they said, “Oh, well, you know, we’ll have to wait two days or whatever it was.” They did. They thought, “Well, she just treat her as a runaway.” But we knew she didn’t.
The original complaint was a missing person’s complaint taken by Flint PD. My name is [music] Detective Sergeant William Art. I was a detective for the Michigan State Police. Sher Joe was 16 years old at the time. She had left for school about 6:45 in the morning walking to the school bus and never made it. And so the police just took a normal missing person complaint at that point in time.
Got a phone call saying that she was missing [music] and my ex-husband now said, um, oh, she’s just probably ran off with her friends. [music] I said, Sherry Joe would not do that. She would not leave and not tell anybody. So, I packed up my stuff and came down to Flint and we got a motel down there and he’ll pass out flyers. We’d go out to eat and I couldn’t eat.
[music] I gained I lost 10 lbs that week cuz every time we’d go into a restaurant, I’d think, “Is Sherry eating? I wonder if she’s eating.” [snorts] It was just a really [music] bad week. [snorts] You see a guy walk in the restaurant or just a guy walking down the street. Is that him? Is he the [music] one that took Sherry? In the days that followed, the family set out to looking for her, contacting family and friends, and you know, people that she knew, looking diligently for her.
Everybody’s looking through dumpsters, looking the alleys. The police did what they needed to do as far as they entered her into the NCIC computer system. So if any police agency had contact with her, it would have popped up that she was missing and we would have reunited her with her parents. I think it was on the actual local news that she was missing.
Crimes Stoppers got involved and put a reward out for her whereabouts. They finally realized, you know, that she didn’t run away. They tried to reenact it, but they didn’t get any calls at all. On November 20th, 1983, 15 miles maybe something like that, uh, north of Flint along Mueller Road in Sagena County, Sherry Joe’s body was found in the ditch by a local trapper that was just checking his traps.
She was face down initially and then of course once she was found that initiated the police response and then police officers, detectives went out and our lab went out to collect evidence from the body. There was very little evidence if you can imagine her body was just off the roadway into the ditch.
So it it was I would say a lack of attempt to hide the body, more of a an attempt to just get rid of the body. Uh, so pushed down into the ditch. Her pants [music] were unbuckled. They guessed that she potentially could have been sexually assaulted and it was obvious she was shot. It’s relatively small crime scene, just the side of the road there. Uh, they didn’t find a bullet. They didn’t find anything else. So property as far as evidence goes is very limited.
She walked away from home. So basically she just had the clothes that were on her back. Detective Doug knocking on our door early Sunday morning and had she wore one of my necklaces to school and he had the had the necklace in his hand [snorts] and he said, “Well, is that Cherries?” I said, “Yeah, this Cherries.” And she said, “Well, she’s dead.
” And she’d been shot four times and raped. And um there’s no easy way to say that. She was my only daughter. Sherry, we ended up face [music] first in this drainage creek. Her whole head was born water. So, she’s in water long enough that she was disfigured. My husband went up and identified her body and um he told his sister that [laughter] I never would have survived it. I got a call that they found her body.
[laughter] [snorts] Just it’s just so unbelievable, you know, [laughter] how how [snorts] could anybody hurt her? I just can’t even imagine why anybody would want to hurt her. And so then I called her dad and um they come right up. [snorts] And so then we had to go make funeral arrangements and stuff. Once her body goes to autopsy, they found that she was shot four times, including one to the head.
She has one to the abdomen, two to the back, and [music] one to the back of the head. They believe that Sherry lived while she was in the ditch and died from lack of [music] uh blood. Uh she at least lived in the ditch for a while before she passed away. I think someone wanted to kill her and hide the body. So, I believe it was somewhat of an execution.
The bullet to the back of the head would be reference to that. Because her pants were undone, they do a sexual assault kit like normal. That kit and its contents are all saved. They collected all of her clothing, including her undergarments. At that time, they did [music] uh clipped fingernails and took swabs of of of their fingernails.
In the ‘8s, ‘ 83, uh DNA really wasn’t uh as big [music] as it as it is now. And so, it was just one of those things they collected maybe for a potential direct match later on. her dad and his wife. We went up and talked to the detective and um then we went and made funeral arrangements and when we picked out the casket, my ex-husband come up and said, “Anyone you want, Joyce? We’ll get that one.
” Thought my sister was pretty brave through the funeral. We didn’t at that time, we still didn’t know, you know, what was going on. And so we had a good friend watch everybody that came in and anybody that looked suspicious. At her funeral, I saw a guy that I asked Choice. [music] I said, “Do you know him?” And she said, “No.” And so she found out it was a long lost cousin that she didn’t know.
Cuz you always hear that they sometimes will show up at the funeral and stuff to show their pride in what they did. In the 80s, Flint was a General Motors town. Automobile manufacturing was very big in Flint. So, a lot of the people that surrounded that area were involved in the manufacturing [music] process of automobiles. Still kind of that way, but back in the 80s, it was full strength.
In that time frame, it was decent neighborhoods. [music] I won’t say the height of manufacturing, but pretty close. So, people were making money. Therefore, [music] crime wasn’t high. Although it’s one of the larger cities in Michigan, Flint is absolutely not immune to the crime problem. And so, when something like this happens, especially with a juvenile, for example, Sherry Joe, [music] the community is outraged. So, initially, Flint PD asked for tips for this crime.
And then it was police job to follow those tips. There were thousands, thousands, and thousands [music] of tips, which most of them they had to run down. One of those tips was about uh her getting into a white van. There was also another one that someone saw her get into a yellow Camaro. One person was telling the police that he seen her getting in a yellow Camaro. I took her picture over there.
I said, “Are you sure this is who you saw getting in the yellow Camaro?” He said, “Yeah.” investigators used our intelligence section to narrow that down and pretty much came up with a spreadsheet of thousands of Camaros [snorts] in that color or vans in that color. And then, you [music] know, at the time they didn’t have all of the technology we have now.
And so they ran down almost all of those tips. Took days and days and days and unfortunately came up [music] with nothing. the person telling the police that he seen her getting in a yellow Camaro, he was lying through his teeth. So, we’re all every time somebody seen a yellow Camaro, we’re all going to find the yellow Camaro. And why he did that, I don’t know, cuz he had a daughter, too.
So, why would he lie? The investigators at the time felt that Robert Schulz, her stepfather, was a good suspect. And as you know, in most of these cases, it typically is someone that the victim knows. [music] And in this case, Robert was the last person to see Sherry Joe alive. And so the police focused on him.
They tried to set him down for a formal interview. He had some inconsistencies in his story. He did not take a polygraph test that was requested. [music] They were trying to accuse my husband of doing that because he was a stepfather, you know, and you always go to family and I tried to tell him, I said, “There’s no way he would hurt her. He wouldn’t hurt any child.
” He was always cautious and he was upset that they were trying to prove that he did it. It was really hard. They [music] tried a surreptitious phone call with him. They allowed Joyce to call him to make a one party consent phone call and nothing was gained from that eventually either. The detective kept asking me questions and he said, “Well, what are you going to do if you find out he murdered her? How am I supposed to fail?” I know we didn’t do it, you know, but what a question to ask.
The police got his DNA and all that. And then it went on for years and we didn’t hear anything. In my opinion, they did what any law enforcement officer would do. They followed as many leads as they could. The detectives over the years have taken about 123 DNA samples. When this happened in ‘ 83, DNA really wasn’t a thing.
Then the lab could do a direct match of one to one, but it wasn’t like today where we could do some sort of genetic genealogy and come up with a suspect. And so they matched or tried to match. Almost everyone they came in contact with interviewed uh anyone that would voluntarily supply and some that didn’t and they ended up getting search warrants for their DNA and unfortunately nothing matched.
There were hundreds and hundreds of people interviewed and contacted reference this case. There were thousands and thousands of leads and they tried to follow up on all those tips. Eventually the leads just dried up and the case went cold from there. [music] One day at a time we worked our way through it.
I was scared for years that I’d get a phone call and say that Joyce was gone. One day she’s condoms. She was laying in Sherry’s bed. [music] I’d have nightmares over saying, “Mom, why haven’t you found me?” I had that for a long time. After a period of years, I honestly didn’t think they were ever going to find who did it. In 2002, the Michigan State Police had a violent crime task force, primarily in the Flint area, uh, that used detectives from around the state that really took another look to try and reopen this case. The task force reinvestigated a lot of the leads that came in. They ran down the car, the
white van, and the yellow Camaro. They reintered people Sherry Joe’s stepfather was focused on in the investigation at that time, too. I think there was like eight detectives that we spoke to over the years. The last time I was there, I said, “I can’t do this anymore.” And unless you got something new to ask me, I said, “I can’t do it.
” I said, “You put me right back to where I was when she first died.” I said, “I can’t go back there.” And she wouldn’t want me to go back there. And so I said, “If you don’t have anything new to ask me, please don’t.” In 2002, most of the people that were talked to provided a voluntary sample. DNA was kind of in its infancy at that time, but not genealogy at all. And so our lab did direct comparisons to well over a hundred samples.
Unfortunately, nothing matched. The same year, a DNA sample from Sher Joe’s case was sent to Cotus, entered into the national database, and never got a hit or a lead. They had identified DNA. They knew the DNA belonged to an unknown male. They’ve already tested the DNA using STR testing.
They’ve put that STR profile into [music] Cotus and there’s no match. And it’s not a surprise because Sher Joe was murdered in 1983 [music] and COTUS did not go into full deployment until the mid90s. So, it was not a certainty that this person would be [music] in Cotus unless they had continued to reoffend over the years. So, the case remained in [music] Cotus, but not tied to a known person.
In 2022, I got a call from a border patrol agent at an airport in Utah. There was a neighbor of Sher Joe’s. He got caught using a fictitious name. He’d been living like 16 years under this false name. He had been interviewed in this case originally and he had left the state of Michigan shortly after Sher Joe’s homicide. And so I sought out a search warrant.
We got a a DNA sample from him. Unfortunately, it didn’t match. But that was the beginning for me in this case that I thought maybe this case could be not that it was closed, but reinvestigated or at least taking another look at given the technology that we have nowadays. We tried to be as surreptitious as possible. I didn’t really want Joyce to know or the family to know we were again reopening this wound for them.
You know, over the years, these files just got put in boxes, tens of thousands of pages from 20 prior detectives, and it would take me years to sort that out. We started a relationship with Western Michigan University.
We took this case down there, [music] and the students were able to organize this case for us. The students are cleared and background checks through Michigan State Police. We worked with the students [music] to determine what was useful and not useful to get everything on a digital platform and they did a phenomenal job. In the late fall of 2025, Michigan State Police reached out to ask if we could examine the DNA [music] to see if it’s suitable for a different kind of testing.
We started off working with local agencies to [music] help them work through unidentified remains and cases involving unidentified suspects. And so several years ago, the Michigan [music] State Police entered into contract with ARAM to examine all the cold cases that they had. I felt that Aram could be beneficial by sending this to them, at least trying. We had nothing to lose at this point.
We had what 40 years of nothing really. And so I know there’s other companies, but we felt that Aram was the best. February 2025, a piece of evidence from this case was sent to Aram. It contained seaman DNA that was found on a sanitary napkin that Sher Joe was wearing that day. We examine the DNA evidence using the typical metrics that we look at, which are generally the quantity of DNA, the quality of the DNA.
You could imagine in the decades since 1983, the DNA is probably not in the pristine shape it was when it was originally deposited at the crime scene. So quality always plays a factor in these older cases. There’s also the consideration of whether there is one contributor or multiple contributors. And we’re always cognizant of nonhuman sources, you know, bacteria, other things that have DNA that could have also deposited onto that evidence.
[music] And looking at all these factors, we came to the conclusion that this DNA evidence would be suitable. So we take on the case and we immediately get to work. I think that’s something people don’t understand. They say, you know, if a case was cold for 40 years, why are you rushing now? In fact, that’s when you should be rushing to get an answer because the people that are the most affected by those answers are often gone.
When a case is that old, the late 70s, early 80s, that’s that edge where where people don’t live forever and and and you don’t want to solve a case and deliver those answers when everyone’s passed. Sherry’s dad, he is dealing with dementia at this point. Her stepfather is no longer around. It is a rush. It’s it’s a rush against time to give people the truth.
Here at Aram, we use forensic grade genome sequencing, which is our forensic [music] process to translate that physical DNA evidence into a DNA profile. Our profile consists of hundreds of thousands [music] of markers called single nucleotide polymorphisms. These hundreds of thousands of markers can tell us a lot about the person we’re looking for, the unknown suspect in this terrible crime.
It can tell us, for example, where in the world they’re from, their biogeographical ancestry. And so we took all that information and we then execute a genetic genealogy search and discover a number of relatives. [music] And so this is very exciting because we’re a few generations away from the person we’re looking for. Aram produces a lead to a lady in Witchaw, Kansas who potentially is a relative of our suspect.
Unfortunately, our lead had 79 grandchildren. At the time, I felt that I wasn’t sure we were going to get anywhere with that many, if you want to call them, suspects. There are dozens of grandchildren that we need to consider as we look to see if any can be excluded and we can further narrow the search for the likely suspect who’s left the unknown DNA at the crime scene.
My partner and I flew to Kansas and when we talked with her, sweet old lady, we did ask for a DNA sample, which she provided. She called her son over. He provided a voluntary sample, too. So, we were able to send those two samples to Aram. From there, we begin to do the genetic genealogy work. It’s not done in isolation. It’s done with Bill at the Michigan State Police. It took us months.
In fact, uh we utilized the Western students doing open- source searches and us, my partner and I working diligently trying to figure out if there was a Michigan connection. At the conclusion of this process, we narrow to a candidate that makes sense to us based on the genealogical and genetic analysis [music] and makes sense to Bill based on the investigative analysis.
In October 2025, we got more information from Aram with a viable what I felt was a viable suspect from Michigan. The forens of genetic genealogy led to Ronnie Collins as the possible perpetrator. Law enforcement went [music] to find him and talk to him. He was 75. He would have been in his early 30s at the time of the crime.
So that fit and he was definitely in the area at the time of the crime. [music] I just simply wanted to talk to him at that point. We spoke over the phone a couple of times. He kind of put me off over the holidays [music] and then we agreed to meet in early January of 2026. I had no intention of arresting [music] Mr. Collins. It was just simply an interview. Uh I waited set up for the interview, waited around.
He never showed up. Early February, I got a search warrant for his DNA. I tried to call him multiple times and he would never call me back or answer. I sought a search warrant through the court for his DNA. My partner and I went to his house and once we [music] contacted his current wife, uh, she told us that the day the interview was supposed [music] to happen, Ronnie Collins committed suicide.
In my opinion, I felt he was a good suspect and he was trying to get out of a prison sentence. That is an outcome that [music] used to shock me. People will refuse to confess. People would want to plead not guilty and go to trial. [music] But now there are hundreds of arrests that are built around these technologies in the United States, if [music] not thousands.
I think people like Ronnie decided that it’s going to be hard to fight this. By all accounts, Ronnie was a good citizen. [music] He had no significant criminal history, good family man, had a good job. He worked at uh Michigan prison. He was a dental hygienist, so he knew what was going to happen if he went to prison. We learned that he was in a band, traveled around Michigan.
He did at the time have a white van that he utilized for [music] his bandmates and and equipment. When this happened in in ‘ 83, one of [music] the tips was about uh her getting into a white van. So, he in all accounts is our suspect for [music] this crime.
Criminals that get away with a crime for 40 plus years are smart. They’re able to hide the fact that they are this monster. [music] These perpetrators are right next to us in plain sight as respected members of our society. I used to [music] think that if you met a murderer, you you’d kind of know something was off. You’d know they were a murderer.
That is such a naive thought. By all accounts, his family and friends had no idea this had occurred. Unfortunately for him, they collected his [music] DNA, had his autopsy, and did that COTUS test in the state lab, [music] confirmed beyond a shadow of a doubt that Ronnie Collins was the perpetrator that raped Sherry Joe in November of 1983.
Joyce [music] and the family have been through multiple investigators over the years. And so I wanted to see what the results were from Aram before I reached out to the family and to Joyce. And so if we had nothing, Joyce would have never known that I even touched this case. [music] Detective Art called me. He said, “It’s confirmed he did do it.
” He says, “Knowing this, how is that going to affect [music] you?” I said, “It’s not going to nothing’s changed. I still can’t hog her. I still can’t tell her I love her.” I said, “So nothing’s changed. It’s still the same.” And he filled us in on some of the information I didn’t know. He said that she uh bled to death in the ditch. And she I just assumed that she had already passed, but he threw in the ditch and she was still alive. What a terrible way to go.
She’s laying in a ditch by herself. It’s cold winter time, half covered in water. And who knows, maybe it was 3 or 4 hours before she bled to death and died. Like, that’s terrible. He had her for like 3 to 4 days. So, I don’t know what she went through in that those days. And that’s going to haunt me because I couldn’t find her. I was angry when I found out he was 75. He got a marriage.
We don’t [music] know if she would have got married. We don’t know if she would had kids. My sister really got robbed there. It was unbelievable. Totally unbelievable. I said, “You [music] got to be kidding me. They finally got somebody.” Joyce was in in between being happy. They found him and it [music] coming right back.
They had it on the obituaries and they were saying, you know, all the people that he knew was around and he was in a band and everyone saying what a good guy he was. I put on there, no he didn’t. He murdered my daughter. And then got so many responses of that they had to take it down because everyone say no he’s not. When we did find out who did it, I told Detective Art, I said, “I wish Bob was here just to see because they put him through hell cuz my husband passed away in January 2025.
So, he’s not here to to hear all of this, but I tell him every day, we got him.” I can’t imagine [music] losing my only child and the person that I loved most in the world being accused of the crime. It goes [music] to show you again that bringing certainty to these investigations as quickly as possible is necessary for people to move forward with their lives.
[music] Now I know who murdered her and I know he’s not going to hurt anybody else, but who knows what he did before that. You know how many other people? At least [music] in my experience, you don’t just go abduct, rape, and kill on your very first occasion. It starts with some type of an assault maybe and progresses into a homicide. Typically that doesn’t just happen on the very first account.
It it may and it may have in this case, but it’s unlikely. I think he’s [music] still got bodies out there. Like there was two girls that come up missing in [music] ‘ 69 with Ronnie. We suspect him in another cold case that happened to two girls that lived in Oscot. Hobley Spencer is their [music] last names. similar situation where it was Halloween.
They had left school early and the last accounts were they were picked up by a person in a white van. The fact of the white van and Ronnie Collins played in a band on that weekend in Oscot makes him a viable suspect. Unfortunately, we don’t have the girls bodies to be able to continue the investigation. We don’t know what transpired between that case and 1983 in the case of Sher Joe Elliott.
I just think there’s some unanswered questions in my mind. You know, suicide is the easy way out. He didn’t have to sit and answer any questions from myself and other investigators or the family. Did he sexually assault her? Yes, absolutely. We can prove that. Does it also mean that Ronnie killed her? My assumption, and I think probably 12 jurors would agree, that if he’s sexually assaulted her, he probably killed her.
Some of the things that revolve around my brain are, was there someone else involved? You know, if we get more tips, we’ll keep investigating. It’s a disappointing dead end in the sense that it will not be possible obviously to investigate further [music] the crime, why it happened, how it happened, and so on. Sherry would not go near anybody that she didn’t know.
So, that guy had to chase her or whatever. Joyce said they didn’t [music] know him, never heard of him before. So he just picked her out of random, I guess. Somehow he got her and and the detectives first said, you know, because her fingernails weren’t broken [music] as if she put up a fight. And I said, if she had a gun pointing at her, I said she would froze. She wouldn’t have done anything.
We’ll never know what the connection was uh with Sher Joe. Through the years in this case, there have been many tips, many, many tips that that have came in. One of those tips uh was someone saw her get into a yellow Camaro. Took days and days and days, months to run down those and unfortunately came up with nothing.
When you’re investigating [music] and you don’t choose to put DNA in the forefront of an investigation and [music] you choose to go by eyewitness statements, they’re often unreliable. This does occur in contemporary cases [music] today as well. We need to use this technology right away. And because of the way the technology works now, not relying on necessarily a chance match or a lead.
For the first time ever, you can work these cases immediately. [music] DNA can lead the investigation. You can read the genetic information and from there directly determine who left the DNA at the crime scene. And that’s not just important for families that are grieving and hurting. It’s [music] important for anyone else that might be wrongfully accused of the crime. Genetic genealogy is just the start of this.
Like I think that ARM is on the right path. Genealogy is going to change for the better over the next 10, 20 years for sure and it’s going to solve lots of other cases. I [music] just want people to know to never give up hope just because [music] it’s been 40 years. Technology is so much better. they will get them with the stuff that they’re doing in their technology with DNA and so forth.
We’ll be one of the last of the few that has to wait 43 years. Michigan State Police have taken Prostep on the cold cases. They need our senators and our congressmen to back up more on this. I had [music] the privilege to be able to meet Sherry’s mom, her aunt, and her uncle. It truly [music] shows you the ripple effects and the deep impact that each one of these cold cases has on somebody, on a family, on a community. It makes you realize how necessary this is.
[music] It also makes me realize that our family grows every time a case solves. and were able to look [music] the people that are our why in the eyes and tell them how honored we were [music] to get to be a part of their case. Sherry deserved a life. She deserved children. [music] That was all taken away from her. She was a phenomenal child. God had an angel when he got her. She was a sweetheart.
She was my one and only daughter. I just ripped my heart out. Detective Art asked me if I would do this and I said yes. So if it gives anybody some hope then I hope that helps them.